If you ever make Pie Charts using the Xtra with FreeHand then the above example may look familiar to you. Notice the drop shadow in a weird place (standard shadows usually go from top-left to bottom-right), large font sizes and strange placement of the Legend on the right.

Of course you can change things like the font size or face as well as scale or move things around like I did above by sub-selecting within the grouped chart.

But, as soon as you edit the chart data again (in the above legend I changed Taxes to Taxes/Bills) with the Xtra, it reverts to the original placement and sizes. This can be very frustrating. Below I describe how to make a Pie Chart without the Xtra that will be more 3D in appearance, though it isn't quite as dynamically editable as the charts created with the Xtra.

2) Next you want to set up the Knife tool. Double click on the Knife tool so you see the above dialog box. Select the Straight option, and set the Width to 0. Lastly make sure the option Close cut paths is turned on.

3) Now before you do any cutting, make sure you know what percentages you want to divide the ellipse into. It's good to kind of draw it out on paper first to get an idea what would look the best. Above I drew a few lines to show where I'm going to cut, and placed them on the Background layer.

4) Now select the ellipse, and choose the Knife tool. The first cut will be on the top of the ellipse. Using the lines in the background as your guide, cut across the ellipse starting on the outside to the inside ending at the center point of the ellipse (example zoomed in slightly).

This creates a closed path where you cut into the ellipse shown above at right. What the path actually is, is a curve point that doubles-back onto itself giving the illusion of a straight line. You can't select the end of the line because of this. Go ahead and play with the cut point a little by stretching out the curve handles to see what I mean. Just make sure you Undo any playing before you continue.

5) This next step is very crucial to making this work correctly. It can sometimes be frustrating but once you get the hang of it, you'll be making Pie Charts in no time.

While the ellipse is still selected, make another cut similar to how you did above on the bottom. Only this time, make sure you end the cut in the exact same spot as the first cut. It may help to zoom in on the intersection area to get the cut exact.

Special Note You may get an error message that says something like "Could not complete your request because the selection is too complex." Just hit OK and try again until you don't get this message.

You'll know if it worked when you see a point appear in the intersection area like the highlighted point above.

5b) Try testing to see if the cutting worked for you by deselecting the ellipse and choosing the new cut shape and pulling it away from the Pie. If you get the whole ellipse shape, then Undo and try Step 5 again until you see something like above.

6) Repeat Step 5 for the remaining cut areas like the above highlighted areas. Again, if you get the error message I noted above, keep trying, you'll eventually get it to cut.

8) Now we're going to add a touch of 3D realism to this Pie Chart. First select all the shapes and Clone them. While the clones are still selected, move them down about an inch or so.

To make this easier to deal with I'll show you how to make one piece of the 3D Pie Chart first. I made a new layer and hid all but one piece of the Pie on that layer. You can do the same if you like.

14) Repeat Steps 9-12 for the remaining slices of the Pie Chart. If all went smoothly, you should now have a Pie Chart ready to go like the above example.